The rather fortunate opportunity arose to taste two Sauternes wines blind together from two grand estates – Chateau d’Yquem and Chateau Rieussec. Â The results were very interesting. Â Would the d’Yquem be an unassailable beacon of Sauternes quality? Â Would it justify being five times the price of the Rieussec? Â Does label matter? Â Would the vintage make a difference? Â The answers on this tasting were “not compared with the Rieussec”, “no”, “not if both labels are good” and “yes”. Â The d’Yquem from the 1989 vintage presented as the fuller bodied, more obvious wine, with evident quality and complexity. Â But perhaps not quite exhibiting the intensity and complexity of a great d’Yquem. Â Interestingly, I thought it resembled a younger Rieussec vintage. Â Conversely, the Rieussec 1988 presented as the more restrained, and possibly more complex wine, giving up its marmalade notes in a quiet but thoughtful and considered manner that suggested a long life ahead. Â The 1989 vintage seems to have been a warmer vintage, and 1988 possibly better regarded.
Chateau d’Yquem 1989, Sauternes
Golden in colour. Â Full bodied in the glass with notes of oak, butter and caramel. Â A very good wine, if rather obvious in bearing. Â (Alc: 13.5%, Region: Sauternes, Bordeaux, Rating: Very Good, Drink: now to 2037, Tasted: Mar, 2017)
Read more:
yquem.fr/int-en/
Other vintages reviewed:Â
| Vintage | Rating | Review |
|
2008
|
Outstanding
|
Chateau Rieussec 1988, Sauternes
Golden in colour. Â Aromas of orange peel and marmalade. Â A fine boned and delicious interpretation of Sauternes that will beguil and reward drinking now or further cellaring. Â A compelling Sauternes. Â (Alc: 14.5%, Region: Sauternes, Bordeaux, Rating: Very Good to Outstanding, Drink: now to 2037, Tasted: Mar, 2017)
Read more:
www.lafite.com/en/the-chateaus/chateau-rieussec/
Other vintages reviewed:
| Vintage | Rating | Review |
|
2003
|
Very Good
|

